5 NFL QBs Fans Hate Despite Winning — And 5 They Love Despite Losing

QB’s in today’s NFL are shaping their legacy as either heroes who lead their team to victory or someone who can’t seem to get over the hump of losing and not winning enough. These quarterbacks are doing everything they can to win it all on the field and dominate for our favorite teams, no matter the outcome. Some quarterbacks are loved and admired for their courage, their ability to soldier through the league’s intensity without winning much, while those who have conquered most of the NFL can be hated at times for winning too much. When a quarterback is hated, there are numerous reasons fans hate them, from their constant success, domination of opponents during the regular season, and always winning a Super Bowl, when there are other quarterbacks we go to see hoist the Lombardi Trophy instead. Regardless of whether these guys will be Hall of Famers or not, some quarterbacks are beloved despite losing a lot, and some are hated, even though they can’t stop winning. Here are five current quarterbacks who win, but are hated, and five quarterbacks who lose, but are loved. Which QBs are loved despite losing a ton, and which ones are hated due to winning? Wins but hated: Patrick MahomesPatrick Mahomes (Amy Kontras-Imagn Images) Even though Mahomes is a three-time Super Bowl champion, three-time Super Bowl MVP, and two-time league MVP, he can be pretty hated for the amount of winning he’s racked up. Mahomes has made the Kansas City Chiefs a Super Bowl dynasty; he’s also received favorable treatment from the refs and has embraced the villain role. Even though the Chiefs missed the playoffs in the 2025 season, fans were very happy to see them out, but with the championship-winning QB returning to action in 2026, he’ll have the potential to bring the Chiefs back to the playoffs. Mahomes knows how to make anyone on the Chiefs become a superstar and a champion, thanks to his winning ways that constantly make NFL fans jealous of his on-field success as a QB.  On top of that, Mahomes’ loved ones can be a bit distracting off the field from the headlines they’ve attracted throughout the years. All of those factors combined make Mahomes one of the more irritating quarterbacks to fans who already dislike the Chiefs and their winning ways. Loses but loved: Justin HerbertNov 30, 2025; Inglewood, California, USA; Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert (10) drops back to pass against the Las Vegas Raiders during the first half at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kiyoshi Mio-Imagn Images Although Justin Herbert led the Chargers to the playoffs three times, he has yet to win a playoff game in his career so far.  Herbert displays elite physicality, is very consistent during the regular season, and has a humble personality. Herbert constantly carries the Chargers on his back when the team’s defense gives out during key playoff games.  He also has had a lackluster offensive line for most of his career, as he is seen running for his life during games. Sure, Herbert has guys like Quentin Johnston and Ladd McConkey to throw the ball to in the 2026 season, but he needs more Pro Bowl-caliber running backs and tight ends to throw to for a stronger offense. The popular QB may not have the championship résumé like Patrick Mahomes, but he tries to be very competitive every week, and we as fans hope he wins his first playoff game sooner rather than later. Wins but hated: Jalen HurtsJalen Hurts (Credit: IMAGN) Hurts is a talented dual-threat quarterback, but when it comes to playing for the Philadelphia Eagles, fans of opposing teams who are rivals to the Eagles don’t like him. Hurts has played dominant football ever since he became the team’s full-time starter in the 2021 season, and has led the Eagles to the playoffs each year so far. He also became a Super Bowl Champion in the 2024 season, when he and the Eagles dominated the Kansas City Chiefs 40-22 in Super Bowl LIX. He also knows how to get the best of everyone around him, which also makes fans of opposing teams jealous.  The “Tush Push” Hurts and the Eagles keep doing throughout games also gets extremely annoying, and the league wants to ban the play outright because of safety concerns, its effectiveness, and the unfair advantage it gives Hurts and the Eagles. In fact, Vegas Insider did a study on the most hated NFL player, and they found that the Eagles’ QB is the most hated player in the league.  It was also reported that Hurts didn’t even listen to his coaches during the 2025 season, as he would utilize his own game plan instead of what his coaches wanted him to run. Loses but loved: Trevor LawrenceSep 14, 2025; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence (16) runs with the ball against the Cincinnati Bengals in the second half at Paycor Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images Lawrence may not be the most elite QB in the league, but he has put in the effort in his game and has led the Jaguars to the playoffs twice so far in his career. Lawrence’s NFL career began in 2021 when he was coached by Urban Meyer, who made the headlines for the wrong reasons, while Lawrence kept a strong personal demeanor throughout that season. He has played inconsistently, as he led the league in interceptions in 2021, but cleaned that up when he had more competent coaches like Doug Pederson and Liam Coen coaching him instead. He’s also had a weak supporting cast around him, as he doesn’t have that elite wide receiver to work with yet. Sure, Lawrence and the Jaguars have Brian Thomas Jr. on the roster, but his play has regressed since his rookie season in 2024. Lawrence will also be without Travis Etienne Jr., as he signed a four-year, $52 million deal with the New Orleans Saints.  Lawrence was also beloved during his collegiate days back at Clemson, as he helped them win the 2019 College Football National Championship Game against the Alabama Crimson Tide 44-16. Wins but hated: Brock PurdyDec 30, 2024; Santa Clara, California, USA; San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13) during the game against the Detroit Lions at Levi’s Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Sergio Estrada-Imagn Images When Purdy took control of the 49ers’ starting job in the 2022 season, fans were surprised at how talented he was, even though he was the final draft pick of the 2022 NFL Draft. He instantly became a winner under Kyle Shanahan’s system and kept the 49ers afloat in the ever-so competitive NFC West. However, Purdy is disliked by opposing fans and skeptics, labeling him as a system quarterback who has elite teammates around him and Shanahan coaching him day in and day out.  Purdy has a lack of elite physical traits compared to other quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Lamar Jackson, even though he made the Pro Bowl once. Purdy always has elite talent surrounding him, as he constantly makes guys look incredible, which makes fans of opposing teams dislike him and his journey into the league. He has also dealt with his fair share of injuries, which hurts the 49ers’ chances in the playoffs and sometimes of reaching the playoffs. Loses but loved: Joe BurrowJoe Burrow (Photo Via Imagn Images) Even though Burrow hasn’t brought the Cincinnati Bengals to the Super Bowl since the 2021 season, he still brings a lot of fight to his game each week. Burrow’s competitive play elevates the team; he doesn’t shy away from losses as he takes his accountability and matures as a player and leader. Burrow has also suffered injuries throughout his playing career, and it stings, as fans want to see him lead the Bengals to a Super Bowl victory.  Most of the Bengals’ problems aren’t Burrow’s fault, but rather the team’s defense struggling to keep up against opposing teams, and the team not surrounding their star QB with the necessary pieces he needs to succeed. Burrow also has a coolness factor not found in other quarterbacks that comes from his humble attitude, style of play, and toughness he displays throughout the weeks.  We hope Burrow wins that elusive Super Bowl in the near future, as it would be well-deserved and a perfect cherry on top for Burrow’s résumé. Wins but hated: Aaron RodgersAaron Rodgers (8) reacts in the second quarter against the Cleveland Browns at Huntington Bank Field. (Ken Blaze-Imagn Images) Although Chicago Bears’ fans still hate Rodgers for all of the pain and torment he put them through, Rodgers has become pretty hated by many NFL fans for a lot of reasons: Rodgers’ questionable off-field behavior has rubbed fans the wrong way; his love-hate relationship with the media is an issue with fans, as he wants to control the narrative, and his polarizing behavior has been irritating. Besides all of that, Rodgers’ winning against our favorite teams has been hard and painful to watch throughout the years. In 2025, he had a decent season, where he led the Pittsburgh Steelers to a 10-7 record with his immense skill set, which has rubbed opposing fan bases the wrong way. However, no one knows if Rodgers will play in 2026 or not, as his mysterious ways also rub fans the wrong way. Despite winning one Super Bowl, Rodgers also has had bad luck in playoff games when it mattered most, as he hasn’t been back to the Super Bowl since the 2010 season, and that also irritates his fans, while fans who don’t like him enjoy it. As of now, no one knows if Rodgers will suit up for the 2026 season, as it drives us crazy to wonder whether he’ll play or not. If Rodgers does play, his haters and critics will be there to point out his flaws during the regular season.  Loses but loved: Baker MayfieldTampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield (6) makes a pass against Detroit Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson (97) during the second half at Ford Field in Detroit on Monday, Oct. 20, 2025. Mayfield has seen some success with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in recent days, but he’s had his hardships on the field, and fans will always appreciate his humble attitude. Mayfield’s selfless play has brought the Browns out of misery and got them into the 2020-21 playoffs and their first playoff win since the 1994 season. He has kept the Buccaneers afloat in the NFC South after Tom Brady retired, but has had limited playoff success. Mayfield is a beloved underdog as he began his collegiate career as a walk-on, who won the Heisman Trophy in 2017, and has always carried that underdog mentality throughout his NFL career, even though he was drafted with the first pick of the 2018 NFL Draft. He is a great influence off the field, thanks to his community engagement, mentoring, and helping out with disaster relief. And similar to Joe Burrow, Mayfield’s personality is very likable and relatable to fans wanting to root for a hard-working QB.  If the Buccaneers somehow improve during the 2026 season and return to the playoffs, we will be rooting for Mayfield and his team to make a serious playoff run for the Super Bowl, depending on how they finish in the regular season. Wins but hated: Lamar JacksonLamar Jackson (Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images) Although Lamar Jackson won two league MVPs, opposing fans don’t like him due to his lack of playoff success, his style of play, and how he negotiates his contracts. Jackson brings elite competitiveness to the Baltimore Ravens, as the way he runs through opposing defenses makes opposing fans jealous during the regular season.  He’s kept the Ravens afloat during the regular season and has adapted as a passer throughout the years.  However, as mentioned earlier, opposing fans don’t like Lamar Jackson, as he’s incredible in the league, which makes them jealous of his athletic prowess as a QB. Not to mention not being able to reach a Super Bowl and falling flat in the playoffs has fans annoyed, despite Jackson and the Ravens having talented rosters that could get them there. Once Lamar captures that elusive Super Bowl, fans will be happy for him, while the haters will continue to wish he were on their teams instead. Loses but loved: Kyler MurraySep 7, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray (1) against the New Orleans Saints during the second half at Caesars Superdome. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images Murray may be 5-foot-10, but he has gifted athletic talents, giving fans fun athletic reels to enjoy during Thursday nights, Sundays, and Monday nights.  Murray’s dual-threat abilities and his gunslinger mentality make him an exciting quarterback to watch on game days. HE has reached the playoffs once in his career, only to be bounced out of the Wildcard Round in a tough 34-11 loss against the Cardinals’ divisional rivals, the Los Angeles Rams.  Murray has dealt with very inconsistent seasons and injuries in recent years, leading to his release from the Cardinals and his signing a one-year deal with the Minnesota Vikings.  Murray was a foundational player who tried his best to get the Cardinals far during his time with them. He even posted a message on social media saying, “I wanted nothing more than to be the one to end the 77-year drought for this organization. I am sorry I failed us. I wish the community and my brothers nothing but the best.” A message like that is humble and from the heart, as the QB meant every word and did everything he could, as we mentioned a second ago.   It’s unknown if Murray will be the starter heading into week one, as the Vikings still have J. J. McCarthy on the roster. Will Murray be able to revive his career under Kevin O’Connell’s coaching? Who knows, but O’Connell has had a history of getting the best out of the quarterbacks he’s coached, and we hope he can get the best out of Murray during the 2026 season.