Justin Herbert

Fair or not, one reality for NFL quarterbacks is that they get all the credit if their team wins… and all the blame if they lose. That’s just a part of playing the most important position in the game. The first part, especially, rings true for many NFL QBs. They are often shielded from blame and get far too much credit that is, most certainly, not justified. With that, let’s dive into the NFL’s 10 most overrated quarterbacks right now. Who are the most overrated QBs in today’s NFL? 10. Kyler MurrayKyler Murray. Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images There’s a crowd that prefers to blame the Arizona Cardinals’ mismanagement for Kyler Murray’s underachievement there. We say it works both ways. The Cardinals gave Murray plenty of talent to work with, namely DeAndre Hopkins, Marvin Harrison Jr., Zach Ertz, James Conner, and Marquise ‘Hollywood’ Brown. Many of you thought Kliff Kingsbury was the guy holding Arizona back, but he hardly fared any better with Jonathan Gannon at the helm. Murray has yet to throw for 4,000 yards in a season. He’s exceeded 24 passing touchdowns once. A career record of 38-48-1? 121 touchdowns, 60 interceptions, and a 92.2 passer rating? Yeah, we’ve seen better. Few NFL QBs are more exciting to watch than Murray when he’s on top of his game. The problem? He’s rarely on top of his game. He usually plays well in the first half of the season before the wheels come off in the second half. For those who think he’ll fully unlock his potential with the Minnesota Vikings? We say keep your expectations reasonable… 9. C.J. StroudHouston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud (Barry Reeger-Imagn Images) The No. 2 pick of the 2023 NFL Draft was lights-out in his rookie year. Stroud completed 63.9 percent of pass attempts for 4,108 yards, 23 touchdowns, and only five interceptions — leading Houston to a surprise AFC South division crown and trip to the Divisional Round. Stroud’s stats noticeably dipped in 2024, but he did just enough to help the Texans defend their AFC South title. They again advanced to the elite eight, falling to the Kansas City Chiefs despite a tremendous effort. But man, was Stroud difficult to watch in 2025. And when you take a deeper dive, Stroud looks more like a game manager who benefits from an elite defense and coaching staff. I mean, his insane rookie season was three years ago now… Stroud only averaged 217.2 passing yards per game in 2025 and had 19 touchdowns vs. eight interceptions. Then he was pathetic in Houston’s two playoff games, throwing two touchdowns against five picks. He single-handedly wasted a generational 2025 Texans defense that gave him every chance to win. So yeah, it’s time to stop thinking of Stroud as a franchise QB. Robert Griffin III and Sam Bradford also had great rookie years. How did the remainder of their careers go? Let’s stop treating Stroud like a legitimate NFL QB until/unless he gets back to that 2023 form. 8. Brock PurdyAug 16, 2025; Paradise, Nevada, USA; San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy (13) warms up before a preseason game against the Las Vegas Raiders at Allegiant Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Stephen R. Sylvanie-Imagn Images There really isn’t much wrong with Purdy as a quarterback. In his three healthy seasons, he led the San Francisco 49ers to three playoff berths, including two NFC Championship Game appearances and a trip to Super Bowl 58. The issue with Purdy is that we’ve seen two other quarterbacks play like him in Kyle Shanahan’s offense. The 49ers’ investing $265 million in Purdy over five years shows that they view him as an MVP-caliber QB. And he ain’t. Jimmy Garoppolo, of all guys, helped the 49ers to two NFC Championship Game appearances and a trip to Super Bowl 54. And dare we say, backup QB Mac Jones was just as effective as Purdy when he had to start eight games in relief. Yeah, Purdy is solid and all. But Kyle Shanahan has never made a quarterback look bad during his career as an assistant slash head coach. Purdy’s fine, but he’s really nothing special. 7. Jared GoffDetroit Lions quarterback Jared Goff (16) makes a pass against Cincinnati Bengals during the second half at Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati on Sunday, Oct. 5, 2025. Detroit Lions fans are obviously thankful for the role Goff has played in helping them emerge as an NFC powerhouse. But let’s not act like Goff is the entire reason why. With all due respect to Goff, it says a lot that a top head coach like Sean McVay couldn’t wait to ditch him for Matthew Stafford. Lo and behold, the Los Angeles Rams win a Super Bowl in their first season with No. 9 at the controls. With both the Rams and Lions, Goff has had the fortune of playing for two top-tier head coaches with elite offensive units. I mean, how many other QBs would falter with a supporting cast of Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jameson Williams, Sam LaPorta, and Jahmyr Gibbs? Goff also hasn’t been money by any means in the postseason. We remember his choke job in the Rams’ loss to the New England Patriots in Super Bowl 53. And his meltdown in the Lions’ shocking 2024 Divisional Round loss to the Washington Commanders. Goff puts up good numbers on a star-studded Detroit offense in the regular-season, yes. So could a ton of other NFL QBs. Now, if he could just prove us wrong by showing up in the playoffs for once… 6. Dak PrescottDak Prescott (Photo via Imagn Images) Prescott is a bit of a tough case here. It feels like half of football fans know he’s not elite. But since he’s the starting quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys, there’s the other half that thinks he’s elite and, if anything, not rated fairly. No, it’s not Dak Prescott’s fault that Jerry Jones has done such a terrible job as the general manager. We feel for Dak that he had Jason Garrett and Mike McCarthy waste the first half of his career. But like…come on. Prescott has been playing on star-studded Cowboys teams his entire career. And Peyton “Freaking” Manning went to a Super Bowl with four different coaches. Sometimes, the QB has to be better at his job than the coach. Dallas, for example, had top-10 scoring offenses and defenses in 2021, 2022, and 2023. Prescott won a single playoff game in that period…against an 8-9 Tampa Bay Buccaneers team in the 2022 Wild Card Round. Whoop-dee-doo. In seven playoff games, Prescott is 2-5 with 14 touchdowns and seven interceptions. Three of those losses came against a considerable underdog at home. He’s an elite regular-season stats machine, yes. But Prescott is just like Auston Matthews and Aaron Judge. Excellent production before the postseason. Then he goes away when the lights shine brightest. But because he plays on a big-market team, he’s hyped up like one of the very best in his sport. He’s good, but far from elite. Two playoff wins in 10 years is the proof in the pudding. 5. Jalen Hurts Dec 20, 2025; Landover, Maryland, USA; Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (1) looks on before the game against the Washington Commanders at Northwest Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Amber Searls-Imagn Images That sound you heard was the screams of angry and baffled Philadelphia Eagles fans. But please, do hear us out… Yes, he’s taken Philly to the playoffs in his first five full seasons as a starter, including two NFC Championships. And yes, a Super Bowl 59 triumph over the Kansas City Chiefs. Credit where it’s due. But folks, so many other quarterbacks could win a Super Bowl with a star-studded offensive line, a generational running back like Saquon Barkley, an elite wide receiver tandem of AJ Brown and DeVonta Smith, and…oh yeah…a top-five defense. His passing numbers will never be elite because he’s a dual-threat NFL QB and plays in a rush-first offense led by Barkley. That’s fine. We’re not just saying Hurts is overrated because he plays on a star-studded team.  He’s also overrated because his production can best be described as “Jekyll and Hyde.” While he was excellent in 2022 and 2024, Hurts had frustrating and inconsistent 2023 and 2025 seasons. Both years, it got so bad that fans began questioning his leadership, wondering whether he might be responsible for any locker room drama. The Eagles cratered late in the 2023 season because their defense was terrible, and Hurts couldn’t lift them. The Eagles were a disappointment in 2025 because Hurts couldn’t elevate the passing game when Barkley had a down year. That’s not the sign of an elite QB. We would honestly like to see how Hurts would play outside of Philadelphia. To us, he’s a slightly above-average QB who plays in the perfect system to maximize his talents. 4. Lamar JacksonBaltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson (Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images) It pains us to put the two-time MVP on this list. But Jackson has had more than enough chances to prove he’s rated fairly. Jackson is unquestionably one of the NFL’s all-time great regular-season quarterbacks. A 76-31-0 record with six playoff appearances in eight years is nothing to scoff at. But if Jackson can make it look so easy in the regular-season…why on earth does he crawl into a shell during the postseason? Jackson is 3-5 in his postseason career with only 10 touchdowns, seven interceptions, and an 84.6 passer rating. His career passer rating of 102.2 in the regular-season, by the way, is tied with Aaron Rodgers for the best ever. But Jackson doesn’t belong in the tier of “elite” quarterbacks until he starts showing up in the postseason. Joe Burrow and Josh Allen don’t have Super Bowl rings, but we’ve seen them both put up plenty of gutsy performances in the playoffs. The same cannot be said about Jackson. Until/unless he translates that regular-season success to the NFL playoffs, Jackson belongs in the “overrated” QB category. 3. Trevor LawrenceJacksonville Jaguars quarterback Trevor Lawrence (16) runs on the field before an NFL football matchup at EverBank Stadium, Sunday, Sept. 21, 2025, in Jacksonville, Fla. The Jaguars defeated the Texans 17-10. We know, we know. T-Law led the Jacksonville Jaguars to a 13-win season and surprise AFC South division crown last year. Good on him. But folks, we’re now five years into Trevor Lawrence’s career. For those of you who just started watching football within the last two years? He was hyped as a generational QB prospect when the Jags selected him first-overall in 2021. Remember how little time it took for other “can’t-miss” QB prospects like Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck, and Joe Burrow to break out? We still haven’t seen a true MVP-caliber version of Lawrence. As fun as the Jags were in 2025? I mean, Lawrence was only 20th in passer rating. Guys like Tyler Shough, Mac Jones, Jacoby Brissett, and Jaxson Dart had a better rating, for crying out loud. Lawrence has yet to reach the 4,200-yard passing mark or 30-TD mark. And that’s despite being surrounded by stud playmakers like Travis Etienne Jr., Brian Thomas Jr., and Calvin Ridley over the years. And since his rookie year, only Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes have thrown more interceptions than Lawrence. Generational? No sir. More like just “above average” if you ask us. 2. Jordan LoveSep 11, 2025; Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA; Green Bay Packers quarterback Jordan Love (10) looks on in the third quarter against the Washington Commanders at Lambeau Field. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-Imagn Images Yeah, it’s time to have a conversation about Jordan Love. The 2020 first-round pick had a remarkable first season as the Green Bay Packers’ full-time starter in 2023 after taking the reins from Aaron Rodgers. Love led the Packers to the postseason after throwing for 4,159 yards, 32 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions. His Packers crushed the Cowboys in the Wild Card Round, then barely fell to the top-seeded San Francisco 49ers in the Divisional Round. That was in 2023. This was supposed to be a team trending up. But Love hasn’t returned to that MVP-like quarterback we saw in 2023. He averaged roughly 20 fewer passing yards per game in 2024 and 2025. And when he missed some time due to injuries? The offense functioned just fine under backup Malik Willis, perhaps indicating that Love may or may not be a system NFL QB. Oh, and the Packers went one-and-done in the 2024 and 2025 playoffs. Love had three interceptions in their 2024 playoff loss to the Eagles. Then he no-showed the second half in their humiliating collapse against the Chicago Bears. Surrounded by an elite supporting cast, there’s no excuse for Love to have a single playoff win in three years. We’re still waiting for his signature moment as a Packer. And beating up on non-playoff teams isn’t what made Aaron Rodgers, Brett Favre, or Bart Starr legendary. If the Packers don’t go on a deep playoff run in 2026, it’ll be time to have a conversation about whether Love is really the guy. 1. Justin HerbertDec 8, 2025; Inglewood, California, USA; Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert (10) runs off field after defeating the Philadelphia Eagles in overtime at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images The Los Angeles Chargers’ signal-caller put up all-world numbers over his first three NFL campaigns. He set numerous passing records, including the most yards through a QB’s first three seasons and most consecutive 4K passing seasons to begin a career. At first, the narrative was that he didn’t have a proper coaching staff or the right supporting cast. Okay, well, the Los Angeles Chargers corrected that by hiring Jim Harbaugh in 2024. He coached the league’s No. 1 scoring defense that year and the ninth-best unit in 2025. And yet, Herbert has not been able to take the Chargers to that next level. His first playoff loss? The Bolts blew a 27-0 lead to the Jaguars in the 2022 Wild Card Round. Then he threw four interceptions in their 2024 playoff loss to the Houston Texans. In LA’s 2025 playoff loss to the New England Patriots? 159 passing yards on 31 attempts. Zero touchdowns. Yippee… So you have a guy who put up all-world numbers at the beginning because he had to throw the ball a lot. Now you have a guy who can’t win a big game despite a top-tier head coach and an elite defense. What more does Herbert once? It’s time to stop treating Herbert like we’re in the early 2020s. He’s not young anymore. At what point do we wonder if he’s really the QB who can take LA all the way?