Total Pro Sports

Every NFL trade that happens changes the league to some degree… But what about the trades that didn’t happen? The ones that were agreed upon—then blocked—or backed out of. The times that General Managers of teams went to bed thinking they had a deal that was going to change the trajectory of their franchise, only to wake up empty-handed. The ones where one phone call, one owner’s grudge, or one failed physical changed the course of NFL history. These ten trades would have reshaped franchises, altered dynasties, and completely changed the careers of some of the biggest names in football. Let’s break down the craziest NFL trades that never happened—and why they fell apart. Why did these trades fail to push through in the NFL? Brian Burns to the Rams (2022)Dec 24, 2022; Charlotte, North Carolina, USA; Carolina Panthers defensive end Brian Burns (53) walks off the field after the win over the Detroit Lions at Bank of America Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jim Dedmon-USA TODAY Sports At the 2022 trade deadline, the Rams offered the Panthers a monster package for edge rusher Brian Burns: two first-round picks and a second-round pick in the NFL Draft, but the Panthers said no to that trade. Scott Fitterer, Carolina’s general manager, saw Burns as a foundational piece. The Panthers had just fired Matt Rhule. They didn’t want to look like they were tanking. They wanted to show the locker room that they were still trying to compete. So they kept Burns. They tried to sign him to a long-term extension. Burns wanted $30 million per year. The two sides couldn’t agree. The Panthers went 2-15 the next season—the worst record in the NFL. Not long after, Burns was demanding a trade, and Carolina’s leverage was gone. The bidding war that never happened. The Panthers finally shipped him to the New York Giants for a second-round pick and a swap of fifth-rounders. Talk about fumbling the bag! Russell Wilson to the Bears (2021)Dec 21, 2021; Inglewood, California, USA; Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson (3) throws the ball during warmups before the game against the Los Angeles Rams at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports Three first-round picks. A third-round pick. Two starters. That’s what the Bears offered the Seahawks for Russell Wilson in March 2021. Ryan Pace, Chicago’s general manager, was all in, putting together one of the most aggressive trade packages in the NFL in recent memory after Wilson had named the Bears as one of four teams he’d waive his no-trade clause for.  Needless to say, Chicago was prepared to mortgage its future. And, man, after seeing how another crazy aggressive trade package for Wilson—the cursed one that Denver put together—played out…  Pace has to be thanking his lucky stars that this deal fell through because the Seahawks were hell-bent on getting one of the stars off of Chicago’s defense as part of the package. Fast forward today, and it looks like it’s all over for Wilson. Raiders Refused to Trade Khalil Mack Across the Bay (2018)Dec 30, 2018; Minneapolis, MN, USA; Chicago Bears linebacker Khalil Mack (52) looks on following the game against the Minnesota Vikings at U.S. Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports The 49ers made the best offer, but unfortunately for San Francisco, the Raiders didn’t care. In September 2018, the Oakland Raiders were shopping Khalil Mack, the 2016 Defensive Player of the Year, who had held out all of training camp. More than half the league called. The Bears, Jets, and 49ers all made serious offers. The 49ers went hard. General manager John Lynch believed San Francisco offered more than anyone else. “I don’t want to beat a dead horse, but we tried like heck to acquire Khalil Mack,” Lynch told 95.7 The Game. “I continue to think we offered a better deal than Chicago.” But instead, the Raiders took Chicago’s offer of two first-round picks, a third-round pick, and a sixth-round pick—a move many suspect they made because of the rivalry between the two franchises… they couldn’t stomach the idea of sending a player of his caliber to a rival… so they didn’t! It is a shame too… Chicago had a nice run with Mack, but they never had enough offense to be serious contenders. That 49ers team really could’ve been special with a generational talent added to their D-line! Ben Roethlisberger to the Rams (2010)December 19, 2010; Pittsburgh, PA, USA: Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger (7) looks on from the sidelines against the New York Jets during the third quarter at Heinz Field. The Jets won 22-17. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-USPRESSWIRE Believe it or not, the Steelers actually tried to trade Ben Roethlisberger. In 2010, Roethlisberger was suspended for six games following allegations of sexual assault.  It was later reduced to four… but his reputation was in shambles, and Pittsburgh’s front office was growing tired of his off-the-field antics. According to multiple reports, the Steelers approached the St. Louis Rams about a trade for the embattled NFL star. Pittsburgh wanted a high draft pick in exchange for its franchise quarterback. The Rams said no. At the time, it seemed like a reasonable decision. The Rams had the first overall pick in the 2010 draft. They were rebuilding. Sam Bradford was the consensus top quarterback prospect. Why give up a premium pick for a quarterback with serious off-field baggage? Here’s what happened next: Roethlisberger came back from his suspension and led the Steelers to a 12-4 record. They won the AFC Championship and reached Super Bowl XLV. Roethlisberger would go on to play another 11 seasons in Pittsburgh, making more Pro Bowls, winning a lot more games, and cementing his Hall of Fame credentials. As for the Rams, well, Bradford showed flashes but never developed into a franchise quarterback. They cycled through coaches and quarterbacks, going nowhere until Sean McVay arrived in 2017, when the Rams turned things around. Sometimes, the trade you don’t make costs you a decade. Stefon Diggs Chose Buffalo Over the Jets (2020)Dec 28, 2020; Foxborough, Massachusetts, USA; Buffalo Bills wide receiver Stefon Diggs (14) runs the ball against the New England Patriots in the second half at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-USA TODAY Sports Stefon Diggs almost became a Jet. By the spring of 2020, Diggs was done in Minnesota. He’d skipped practices. He’d been fined $200,000. And he’d told reporters, “There’s truth to all rumors,” when asked about demanding a trade to a different NFL team. The Vikings were ready to move on. After the season ended, Diggs’s options crystallized. It was Buffalo or the Jets. “After the season, I was like, man, it’s either I go there, or it was like the Jets or somewhere like that,” Diggs said. “I was like, I’m gonna go to Buffalo and see what’s going on.” He picked the Bills, and the trade sent shockwaves through both franchises.  Minnesota used that first-round pick on a receiver out of LSU named Justin Jefferson. In Buffalo, Diggs unlocked Josh Allen. In his first season with the Bills, Diggs led the NFL with 127 catches and 1,535 receiving yards, and Allen’s completion percentage jumped from 58.8% to 69.2%.  And… of course… the Jets, well, they remained the Jets. Bills Wanted Christian McCaffrey (2022)Dec 24, 2022; Santa Clara, California, USA; San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey (23) walks off the field after defeating the Washington Commanders at Levi’s Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports Before Christian McCaffrey became the centerpiece of San Francisco’s offense, the Buffalo Bills were circling—and, man, we could be looking at a completely different NFL landscape had they been able to pair him with Josh Allen. Back in October of 2022, the Panthers had just fired Matt Rhule. McCaffrey was the most valuable asset on the roster. The Bills desperately needed a dynamic running back. Josh Allen was doing everything himself. Adding McCaffrey seemed like the missing piece. Bills GM Brandon Beane called the Panthers. Multiple times. He stayed in touch throughout the entire process. But he never made a firm offer. “Yes, that was the last draft I was there in Carolina. Know him well,” Beane told reporters. “When you hear he’s on the block, I wouldn’t be doing my due diligence to not look into that. I did speak to the Panthers GM. Never made him an offer, but did stay in touch through the process.” Why didn’t Buffalo pull the trigger? “Ultimately, it was going to be more than we were going to be able to do.” The 49ers didn’t hesitate. They offered second-, third-, and fourth-round picks in 2023, plus a fifth-rounder in 2024. McCaffrey went on to lead the NFL in rushing in 2023, won Offensive Player of the Year, and helped San Francisco reach the big game. The Bills brought in Nyheim Hines instead. And every time McCaffrey torches a defense, Buffalo fans wonder what could have been. Buffalo is fortunate that James Cook developed into a consistent producer; otherwise, they really would’ve been sick over this one… Larry Fitzgerald to the Eagles (2008)January 29, 2008; Tampa FL, USA; Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Larry Fitzgerald (11) at the Cardinals press conference at the Hyatt Plaza hotel. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports Larry Fitzgerald should have been an Eagle. In 2008, the Arizona Cardinals were strapped for cash. Fitzgerald was due to make $14.6 million that year and $17.3 million the next. The back end of his rookie contract had the team over a barrel with a gigantic cap number. The Eagles came calling. According to Fitzgerald himself, Philadelphia offered to trade a first-round pick and a third-round pick for the perennial NFL All-Pro receiver. Arizona seriously considered it, but ultimately, the Cardinals signed Fitzgerald to a four-year, $40 million extension with a no-trade clause, keeping their franchise cornerstone in place. Here’s the twist: Later that same season, the Eagles and Cardinals met in the NFC Championship Game. Fitzgerald destroyed Philadelphia. Nine catches, 152 yards, and three touchdowns—en route to the Cardinals winning the contest 32-25 to advance to Super Bowl XLIII. The Eagles suffered their fourth NFC Championship loss of the decade—and got torched by the receiver they almost traded for. Fitzgerald went on to become the second-leading receiver in NFL history. He played his entire 17-year career in Arizona. The Eagles? They spent years searching for a true number-one receiver. One trade rejection turned into one championship game destruction.  Deshaun Watson to the Saints (2022)Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson comes off the field after practice during the NFL football team’s football training camp in Berea on Aug. 4, 2022. Watson File Photo 5 The New Orleans Saints did everything right. It still wasn’t enough. In March 2022, Deshaun Watson was finally available. A grand jury had declined to indict him on criminal charges, and the Texans were ready to deal. Watson had a no-trade clause, so he controlled his destiny. Four teams made serious offers: the Panthers, Falcons, Browns, and Saints. New Orleans went all in. The Saints were the only team to get a second meeting with Watson. Owner Gayle Benson flew in personally. They restructured contracts across the roster to clear cap space. They put together a trade package that would have sent multiple first-round picks to Houston. By Thursday , Watson had eliminated the Panthers and Browns. It was down to two NFC South rivals: the Saints and the Falcons. New Orleans had every reason to feel confident. They had the better roster. They had the more urgent need—Drew Brees had retired, and they’d just gone 9-8 with four different starting quarterbacks. Watson meeting with Benson twice signaled a serious interest. Then Friday morning happened. Watson’s agent called the Browns—the team Watson had eliminated 24 hours earlier—and said Cleveland was back in play. The Browns offered something no other team would match: a five-year, $230 million contract that was fully guaranteed. The Saints couldn’t compete with that. Neither could Atlanta. The Panthers had already been eliminated because they wouldn’t guarantee years three and four. Watson chose the money. He went to Cleveland, where his future remains uncertain. As a result, Baker Mayfield got sent on the odyssey that has since landed him in Tampa Bay, and while the Saints haven’t made the most of this epic bullet dodged, there is no denying that they ended up in a way better spot than the Browns. Pete Rozelle Blocked John Elway's move to the Raiders (1983)Denver Broncos — John Elway, 1983-1998, 51,475 yards Xxx C10 90 Elway 26 S Fbn Co The Raiders thought they had John Elway. The deal was done. Al Davis had put together a package the Colts couldn’t refuse: three first-round picks and two second-round picks for the number-one overall selection. Ernie Accorsi, Baltimore’s general manager, later confirmed it would have been “the best package ever” for Elway. There was just one problem: Davis needed another first-round pick in the NFL Draft to make the trade work. He went to the Chicago Bears, who had the sixth overall selection. The Raiders offered Howie Long, draft picks, and other assets. The Bears were receptive. The deal was closed. Then the night before the draft, everything fell apart. Bears GM Jim Finks called Raiders director of football operations Steve Ortmayer. “It’s not going to happen,” Finks said. “They’re not going to let it happen.” By “they,” everyone understood he meant the NFL league office—and specifically, Commissioner Pete Rozelle. “We almost had Elway, but Pete Rozelle voided the trade,” Ron Wolf, a former Raiders personnel executive now in the Hall of Fame, said years later. “We had the trade set up with Baltimore, but Pete wouldn’t let it happen.” Rozelle and Davis hated each other. Davis had been AFL commissioner during the merger negotiations in 1966, and Rozelle edged him out for the unified NFL commissioner job. Davis later sued the NFL over his franchise’s move to Los Angeles—and won, collecting $35 million in damages. And as a result… The Broncos acquired Elway for a far inferior package: backup quarterback Mark Herrmann, tackle Chris Hinton, and a first-round pick. Elway went on to win two Super Bowls and become one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. Have to think that Davis was wishing that he didn’t play hardball with Rozelle after that one! Randy Moss and Aaron Rodgers Almost Became Raiders/Packers (2007)Nov. 29, 2007; Irving, TX, USA; Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (12) reacts as the game ends against the Dallas Cowboys at Texas Stadium. Dallas defeated Green Bay 37-27. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports During the 2007 NFL Draft, the Raiders were shopping Randy Moss. He’d been a disaster in Oakland—just 43 catches the year before—and they wanted out. Two teams were seriously interested: Green Bay and New England. Allegedly, the Raiders floated a trade that would have sent Moss to Green Bay in exchange for Aaron Rodgers. Think about that. Rodgers was a backup entering his third year, an unproven commodity sitting behind Brett Favre. The Packers had Favre committed to playing a few more years. Moss would give him a weapon to chase another Super Bowl. Rodgers might never get a chance in Green Bay anyway. The Raiders held the first overall pick in the 2007 draft. If they’d gotten Rodgers, they could have traded that pick or selected Calvin Johnson at number two. But the two sides couldn’t agree on the additional draft compensation. The Raiders wanted more. The Packers wouldn’t budge. So the trade shifted to a simpler version: Moss for a draft pick… and Green Bay was outbid by New England because they wouldn’t budge from a 5th round pick—which in retrospect is a hilarious and terrible move… though I’m sure once Rodgers led them to a Super Bowl in 2010 they felt a sense of relief too… As per usual, the Raiders ended up down a bad path… instead of Rodgers, the Raiders drafted JaMarcus Russell—arguably the biggest bust in NFL history.