Buffalo Bills

As the years pass, amazing talent comes and then goes in the NFL. We get to enjoy watching the next superstar carve out a Hall of Fame career during their time in the league, and NFL fans are shelling out serious dough to see their favorite players enshrined.  Although many have risen to the heights and have been enshrined in Canton, some shone brightly on the field but haven’t heard their names called to Canton. Lets take a look at Every NFL Team’s Best Player Who Somehow Isn’t in the Hall of Fame. Do these guys deserve a spot in the NFL Hall of Fame? Arizona Cardinals: Adrian WilsonNov. 25, 2012; Glendale, AZ, USA: Arizona Cardinals safety Adrian Wilson against the St. Louis Rams at University of Phoenix Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports Wilson did it all for the Red-Birds. He made five Pro Bowls, had 25.5 sacks, 27 interceptions, and four defensive touchdowns, and helped the team reach Super Bowl XLIII.  Even though many of the Cardinals’ teams Wilson was on weren’t standouts, he was a major bright spot for them on defense.  Atlanta Falcons: Tommy NobisAug 1969; Boston, MA, USA; FILE PHOTO; Boston Patriots running back Jim Nance (35) carries the ball pursued by Atlanta Falcons linebacker Tommy Nobis (60) during a pre-season game at Alumni Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Dick Raphael-USA TODAY Sports Nobis was the first pick for the Falcons when they were established in 1966, making a name for himself with his physical attributes, mental acuity, and excellent work ethic. Though not enshrined in Canton, he won the 1966 Defensive Rookie of the Year award, made five Pro Bowls, and made the NFL 1960s All-Decade team.  Baltimore Ravens: Marshal YandaSep 29, 2019; Baltimore, MD, USA; Baltimore Ravens offensive guard Marshal Yanda (73) looks on during a football game against the Cleveland Browns in the second quarter at M&T Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mitchell Layton-USA TODAY Sports Yanda played his entire 13-year career with the Ravens, where he made eight Pro Bowls, helped the team win Super Bowl XLVII, and made the NFL 2010s All-Decade team.  With these accomplishments, Yanda should be enshrined in the Hall of Fame. Hopefully, that day will come soon.  Buffalo Bills: Steve Tasker Tasker, regarded as one of the best special teams players in the league, made seven Pro Bowls and helped the Bills reach four straight Super Bowls, thanks to the agility he brought to punt and kickoff returns. However, the Bills lost all of them.  Sadly, Tasker isn’t in the Hall of Fame for his deserving on-field performance. History would do well to remember this bright spot of the 1990s Bills. Carolina Panthers: Luke Kuechly Dec 15, 2019; Charlotte, NC, USA; Carolina Panthers middle linebacker Luke Kuechly (59) looks back to the ref after a play against the Seattle Seahawks during the second half at Bank of America Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jim Dedmon-USA TODAY Sports Kuechly terrorized opposing offenses with his elite athleticism, football intelligence, and serious work ethic. He earned the 2013 NFL Defensive Player of the Year award, played in seven Pro Bowls, had 12.5 sacks, and helped the Panthers reach Super Bowl 50. Kuechly hasn’t been enshrined in the Hall of Fame since retiring at the age of 28, but we hope the fates turn his way soon. Chicago Bears: Jay HilgenbergJan 26, 1986; New Orleans, LA, USA; FILE PHOTO; Chicago Bears center Jay Hilgenberg (63) walks off the field during the second half of Super Bowl XX against the New England Patriots at the Superdome. The Bears defeated the Patriots 46-10. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports Hilgenberg, regarded as one of the best centers to play in the league, anchored the dominant Bears’ offensive line for most of his career. He helped the team win Super Bowl XX, made seven Pro Bowls, and started in 152 out of 188 games as a pro.  It’s shameful that Hilgenberg isn’t enshrined in Canton, as seven of his teammates from the 1985 team that won the Super Bowl are. We hope to see Hilgenberg become the eighth guy from that legendary team enshrined. Cincinnati Bengals: Ken AndersonOct 27, 1974; Cincinnati, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO; Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Ken Anderson (14) in action against the Houston Oilers at Riverfront Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY NETWORK Anderson was one of the most accomplished quarterbacks in the 1970s and ’80s for his accomplishments in Cincinnati. He helped the Bengals reach Super Bowl XVI, won the 1981 NFL MVP award, won the 1981 NFL Comeback Player of the Year award, and made four Pro Bowls.  It’s rather unfair that Anderson isn’t enshrined in Canton. Hopefully, this Bengal legend is enshrined in Canton in our lifetime. Cleveland Browns: Clay Matthews Jr.Sep 22, 2019; Cleveland, OH, USA; Cleveland Browns former player Clay Matthews Jr. attends the game against the Los Angeles Rams at FirstEnergy Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports Matthews Jr. was a fierce linebacker who dominated opposing offenses in the 1980s. Matthews Jr. helped the Browns reach the AFC Championship game three times, made four Pro Bowls, and led the league in combined tackles four times. With all that Matthews Jr. accomplished, it’s painful not to see him enshrined in Canton. He and those 1980s Browns teams deserve more recognition.  Dallas Cowboys: Everson WallsJan 22, 1983; Washington, DC, USA; FILE PHOTO; Dallas Cowboys defensive back Everson Walls (24) on the field during the 1982 NFC Championship Game against the Washington Redskins at RFK Stadium. The Redskins won 31-17. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports Walls had a very successful NFL career with the Cowboys throughout the 1980s. He played for legendary head coach Tom Landry, made four Pro Bowls, led the league in interceptions in 1981, 1982, and 1985, and helped the Giants win Super Bowl XXV.  Despite all his accomplishments on defense throughout his career, Walls wasn’t enshrined in Canton during his last year of eligibility for modern-era talent. He may soon be enshrined as a senior candidate. Denver Broncos: Tom Nalen Nalen was an outstanding center who played his entire 14 seasons with the Broncos. He helped the team win back-to-back Super Bowls, made five Pro Bowls, and started in 188 out of 194 games as a Pro.  Nalen sadly isn’t in the Hall of Fame. Truth is, centers rarely get in, and other centers with stronger resumes have trumped his inclusion. However, Nalen is enshrined in the Broncos’ Ring of Fame. Detroit Lions: Herman MooreOct 25, 1992; Tampa, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Detroit Lions receiver Herman Moore (84) in action against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Tampa Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Lou Capozzola-USA TODAY NETWORK Moore played a significant role for the 1990s Lions, helping the team reach the 1991-92 NFC Championship game. Moore made four Pro Bowls, had four 1,000-receiving yard seasons, led the league in receptions twice, and scored 62 touchdowns in “the Motor City.” Moore isn’t enshrined in Canton. Wide receivers have very high standards for getting in when they’re eligible. Moore is enshrined in the Pride of the Lions. Green Bay Packers: Ahman GreenAugust 5, 2005; Green Bay, WI, USA; Ahman Green #30 of the Green Bay Packers gets tackled from behind by the Buffalo Bills during the scrimmage at at Lambeau Field. Mandatory Credit: Photo By Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports Copyright (c) 2005 Jeff Hanisch Green was a force to be reckoned with in the 2000s as he bulldozed his way through opposing defenses. Green made four Pro Bowls, scored 60 rushing touchdowns throughout his career, and helped the Packers reach the playoffs five times. Green isn’t enshrined in Canton. His stats may not be elite enough for consideration, and playing in an era with other running backs like Ladanian Tomlinson, Adrian Peterson, and Edgerrin James may have hurt. Green is enshrined in the Packers’ Hall of Fame. Houston Texans: Arian FosterOct 18, 2015; Jacksonville, FL, USA; Houston Texans running back Arian Foster (23) runs during the second half of a ootball game against the Jacksonville Jaguarsat EverBank Field. Mandatory Credit: Reinhold Matay-USA TODAY Sports Although Foster’s NFL career was short, he made the most of it with the Texans. He made four Pro Bowls, helped the Texans reach the playoffs twice, and led the league in rushing yards in 2010.  Foster isn’t enshrined in Canton due to his short career riddled by injuries, not enough volume on the ground, and those high standards for Hall of Famers. Plus, Foster also fueled some rumors about how the NFL is ‘rigged.’ The Texans should enshrine Foster in their Ring of Honor immediately. Indianapolis Colts: Reggie WayneReggie Wayne Reggie Wayne scored 82 touchdowns during his NFL career.Reggie Wayne Colts Fall Arts Guide The 2000s Colts had it all: Peyton Manning, Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James, and Reggie Wayne, who also dominated opposing defenses. Wayne helped the Colts win Super Bowl XLI. He made six Pro Bowls, led the league in receiving yards in 2007, and scored 82 touchdowns.  Wayne hasn’t been enshrined in Canton due to a logjam at wide receiver, which makes it very difficult to make a wideout selection. Potentially, he may have been in Marvin Harrison’s shadow. Wayne is enshrined in the Colts Ring of Honor.  Jacksonville Jaguars: Mark BrunellSep 3, 2000; Cleveland, OH, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Mark Brunell (8) throws in the pocket against the Cleveland Browns at Cleveland Browns Stadium. The Jaguars beat the Browns 27-7. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Emmons-USA TODAY Sports Although Brunell was a backup at times, his tenure with the Jaguars is memorable. He made three Pro Bowls with the team, helped the Jags reach the AFC Championship game twice, and led the league in passing yards in 1996. Brunell isn’t in Canton due to a lack of dominance, injuries, and intense competition with other quarterbacks like Peyton Manning, Brett Favre, and Jim Kelly. Brunell is enshrined in the Pride of the Jaguars. Kansas City Chiefs: Otis TaylorOtis Taylor of the Kansas City Chiefs gets some comforting words from the assistant coach on the sidelines during the Super Bowl at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum in Los Angeles, Calif., Jan. 15, 1967. Taylor is one of the stars of the Chiefs, but the Green Bay Packers won the game 35-10. Otis Taylor Taylor was one of Len Dawson’s favorite passing targets, even saying, “Otis made my job easy. If you got to pass to Otis, you know he’d catch it.” He helped the Chiefs win Super Bowl IV, might’ve been robbed for a Super Bowl MVP in the process, helped them win two AFL Championships, made two Pro Bowls, and led the NFL in receiving yards in 1971.  Taylor isn’t enshrined in Canton due to subpar statistics compared to other wide receivers like Paul Warfield, Don Maynard, and Fred Biletnikoff. Taylor is enshrined in the Chiefs Hall of Fame.  Las Vegas Raiders: Lester HayesNov 16, 1986; Los Angeles, CA, USA: FILE PHOTO; Los Angeles Raiders defensive back Lester Hayes (37) in action against the Cleveland Browns at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. Mandatory Credit: Long Photography-USA TODAY Sports Hayes was a dominant cornerback for the Raiders when they were in Oakland and Los Angeles. He helped the “Silver and Black” win two Super Bowls, made five Pro Bowls, led the league in interceptions in 1980, and was the 1980 NFL Defensive Player of the Year winner. Hayes isn’t in the Hall of Fame mainly due to his use of stickum, which was banned by the NFL. After the league banned stickum, Hayes’ interception numbers declined, and he suffered thumb injuries.  Los Angeles Chargers: Leslie O’Neal O’Neal had a very impressive tenure with the Bolts during the 1980s and 1990s. He helped the team reach Super Bowl XXIX, made six Pro Bowls, had 132.5 sacks, and was the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in 1986.  As dominant as O’Neal was, he isn’t in Canton due to the lack of team success for the Chargers during that era. O’Neal is enshrined in the Chargers’ Hall of Fame.  Los Angeles Rams: Torry HoltDec. 30, 2007; Glendale, AZ, USA; St Louis Rams wide receiver Torry Holt (81) stiff arms Arizona Cardinals safety Terrence Holt (42) during the first quarter at University of Phoenix Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rick Scuteri-US Presswire It is a crime by the NFL that Holt is not in the Hall of Fame. All he’s done is make seven Pro Bowls, help the team win Super Bowl XXXIV, lead the league in receiving yards twice, and score 74 touchdowns.  The explanation for Holt’s absence from Canton varies, as some fans speculate there’s a crowded wide receiver field, voters believe there are enough Rams’ players from that era already, and the lack of a Super Bowl MVP. The disrespect continued, and even ESPN got Holt’s name wrong in one of their tweets. Get this man to Canton, NFL. Miami Dolphins: Mark ClaytonSep 17, 1989; Foxboro, MA, USA: FILE PHOTO; Miami Dolphins receiver Mark Clayton (83) in action against the New England Patriots at Foxboro Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Dick Raphael-USA TODAY Sports Clayton was a competitive wide receiver for the Dolphins who made things miserable for opposing defenses in the 1980s and early ‘90s. He made five Pro Bowls, helped the Dolphins reach Super Bowl XIX, scored 84 touchdowns, and holds the record for most touchdowns scored for the Dolphins franchise. Voters in the Pro Football Hall of Fame discount Clayton due to being a product of playing with Dan Marino during his Hall of Fame career and a lack of success during the playoffs. It would be very nice to see Clayton get into Canton one day. Minnesota Vikings: Jim MarshallJan 11, 1970; New Orleans, USA; FILE PHOTO; Minnesota Vikings defensive end Jim Marshall (70) on the sideline against the Kansas City Chiefs during Super Bowl IV at Tulane Stadium. The Chiefs defeated the Vikings 24-7. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports Marshall made a name for himself in “the Land of 10,000 Lakes” as a member of the “Purple People Eaters” defense. Marshall made two Pro Bowls, helped the Vikings reach Super Bowl IV, and holds the NFL record for most consecutive games played with one team, with 270 games under his belt. Despite his accolades, Marshall isn’t enshrined in Canton due to a lack of First-Team All-Pros and the infamous “Wrong-Way-Run” against the 49ers in 1964. Marshall is enshrined in the Vikings’ Ring of Honor. New England Patriots: Adam VinatieriFeb 3, 2002; New Orleans, LA, USA; New England Patriots kicker Adam Vinatieri (4) kicks during Super Bowl XXXVI against the St. Louis Rams at the Louisiana Superdome. The Patriots defeated the Rams 20-17. FILE PHOTO; Mandatory Credit: USA TODAY Sports Vinatieri was a crucial piece in the Patriots’ becoming a dynasty in the 2000s. He kicked two game-winning field goals for the Pats in Super Bowls XXXVI and XXXVIII, helped the team win Super Bowl XXXIX, made three Pro Bowls, and holds the record for the most consecutive field goals made in the league with 44. With all of those accolades in the NFL, Vinatieri never got enough votes to get enshrined in Canton, and a potential bias against kickers. Vinatieri is still regarded as one of the best kickers of all time.  New Orleans Saints: Joe HornOct. 29, 2006; New Orleans, LA, USA; New Orleans Saints (87) Joe Horn celebrates after scoring a touchdown in the second quarter of the Baltimore Ravens at New Orleans Saints game at the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans, LA. Mandatory Credit: Matt Stamey-USA TODAY Sports Copyright Matt Stamey Horn gave the Saints life in the 2000s, with his touchdown celebration in 2003, his four Pro Bowl nods, and helping the Saints reach the 2007 NFC Championship game.  While Horn was a great wideout in the “Big Easy,” he unfortunately doesn’t have enough accolades to be enshrined in Canton. The Saints have enshrined Horn in their Hall of Fame.  New York Giants: Phil SimmsSep 7, 1980; St. Louis, MO, USA; FILE PHOTO; New York Giants quarterback Phil Simms (11) sets to throw against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium. The Giants defeated the Cardinals 41-35. Mandatory Credit: Herb Weitman-USA TODAY Sports Simms became the face of the Giants in the 1980s and early ‘90s, as he led the team to two Super Bowl wins. Simms also made two Pro Bowls, was the NFL Man of the Year winner in 1993, and holds the highest completion percentage in a Super Bowl with 88 percent in Super Bowl XXI.  Simms isn’t enshrined in Canton, as he was considered to be only an average quarterback due to a lack of standout statistics. Simms is enshrined in the Giants’ Ring of Honor.  New York Jets: Wesley WalkerSep 21, 1986; E. Rutherford, NJ, USA; FILE PHOTO; New York Jets receiver Wesley Walker (85) celebrates with teammates during the game against the Miami Dolphins at Giants Stadium. Mandatory Credit: USA TODAY Sports Walker was an outstanding wide receiver for the Jets in the 1970s and ‘80s. He made two Pro Bowls, led the NFL in receiving yards in 1978, and scored 71 touchdowns. Walker isn’t enshrined in Canton due to lower peak stats and a lack of individual accolades. Walker is enshrined in the Jets’ Ring of Honor.  Philadelphia Eagles: Donovan McNabbOctober 6, 2002;Jacksonville,FL,USA; #5 Quarterback Donovan McNabb of the Philadelphia Eagles scrambles against the Jacksonville Jaguars at Alltel Stadium. CREDIT: Paul Chapman/ USA TODAY Sports McNabb was the face of the Eagles during the 2000s, as he made six Pro Bowls, led the Eagles to a Super Bowl XXXIX appearance, and four NFC Championship games. McNabb isn’t enshrined in Canton due to a lack of Super Bowl wins and his perceived lack of dominance in his prime years. McNabb is enshrined in the Eagles’ Hall of Fame.  Pittsburgh Steelers: L. C. GreenwoodNov 21, 1976; Pittsburgh, PA, USA; FILE PHOTO; Pittsburgh Steelers defensive tackle L.C. Greenwood (68) in action against the Houston Oilers at Three Rivers Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tony Tomsic-USA TODAY NETWORK Greenwood was a standout defensive end in the 1970s, as he was a part of the Steel Curtain defense, helped the team become a Super Bowl dynasty, made six Pro Bowls, and had 78 sacks. Unfortunately, Greenwood isn’t enshrined in Canton due to a lack of statistics compared to other Hall of Fame defensive ends from his era. Greenwood is enshrined in the Steelers’ Hall of Fame.  San Francisco 49ers: Billy WilsonJan 5, 2025; Glendale, Arizona, USA; Detailed view of a San Francisco 49ers helmet at State Farm Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images Wilson played in a much different era of football back in the 1950s. Wilson scored 49 touchdowns, made six Pro Bowls, and led the league in receptions three times. Wilson isn’t in Canton due to a lack of a championship from his resume, and he played in the NFL playoffs once, which was during the 1957 Conference Playoff against the Lions.  Seattle Seahawks: Shaun AlexanderJan. 5, 2008; Seattle, WA, USA; Seattle Seahawks running back Shaun Alexander (37) rushes the ball against the Washington Redskins during the NFC wild card game at Qwest Field. Seattle defeated Washington 35-14. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports Alexander bulldozed his way through opposing defenses in the early 2000s. Alexander made three Pro Bowls, helped the Seahawks reach Super Bowl XL, and won the 2005 NFL MVP award. Alexander isn’t enshrined in Canton due to his short peak performance and having to deal with other competitive running backs. Alexander is enshrined in the Seahawks Ring of Honor. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Mike AlstottNov 1, 1998; Tampa, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Tampa Bay Buccaneers running back Mike Alstott (40) in action against the Minnesota Vikings at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: USA TODAY Sports Alstott was a bruiser of a fullback, thanks to his powerful running style, which broke tackles. Alstott made six Pro Bowls, helped the Bucs win Super Bowl XXXVII, and scored 58 rushing touchdowns. Alstott is sadly not in Canton due to the position he played and his stats. Alstott is in the Bucs’ Ring of Honor.  Tennessee Titans: Eddie GeorgeTennessee Titans running back Eddie George pumps his fist as he walks off the field after the they defeated the Philadelphia Eagles 27 to 24 in their home and season opener at the Adelphia Coliseum on Sept. 8, 2002. George was a bruising running back who helped elevate the Titans’ offense in the 1990s and early 2000s. George helped the team reach Super Bowl XXXIV, made four Pro Bowls, and scored 68 rushing touchdowns.  George isn’t enshrined in Canton due to a lack of a Super Bowl and low career yards per carry. George is in the Titans’ Ring of Honor. Washington Commanders: Joe TheismannDec 30, 1984; Washington, DC, USA; FILE PHOTO; Washington Redskins quarterback Joe Theismann (7) in action against the Chicago Bears during the 1984 NFC Divisional Playoff Game at RFK Stadium. The Bears won 23-19. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports Theismann made Washington a force to be reckoned with in the early 1980s. He helped the Washington win XVII, made two Pro Bowls, and was the NFL MVP in 1983. Theismann isn’t in Canton due to a short peak and the career-ending injury he suffered in 1985. Nonetheless, his loyalty to the team after retirement has been visible throughout the years. Theismann is enshrined in Washington’s Ring of Fame.